Is Ukraine still part of Europe? Does Zelenskyy's government really want to join the EU?

Is Ukraine still part of Europe? Does Zelenskyy's government really want to join the EU?
Collage: Andrii Kalistratenko, Ukrainska Pravda

"Sanctions were imposed on Russia for its aggression, not for its willingness to talk. So we can only link the lifting of sanctions to progress towards ending the war. Because in the trilateral format [of negotiations – ed.], you could find yourself in a situation where nothing has been resolved, but the sanctions have already been lifted."

These rather confrontational remarks were made by Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy as he described the new political reality in relations with the United States in an interview with TSN on 25 October.

For Zelenskyy to make such strong statements just over a week before the crucial US midterm elections, there must have been compelling reasons.

Advertisement:

And there were. The incumbent White House administration had pivoted towards appeasing Vladimir Putin and intensifying a negotiation process that was increasingly looking less like diplomacy and more like an attempt to force Ukraine into capitulation.

On the night of 3-4 November, Trump's party suffered a crushing defeat in both chambers of Congress, giving Ukraine hope that US policy might at least become more balanced.

But the White House's attempted policy reversal, with complete disregard for Ukraine's interests, raised a fundamental question: who can Kyiv count on as a reliable ally in the long term?

On 28 February 2022, day four of the full-scale war, Zelenskyy, together with then PM Denys Shmyhal and Speaker Ruslan Stefanchuk, signed Ukraine's application to join the European Union.

And indeed, European integration has been the Ukrainian state's guiding light since the very beginning of the full-scale invasion.

Over the past year, however, the Ukrainian government's actions have increasingly contradicted its stated strategic objectives.

On the one hand, the Ukrainian authorities have continued to negotiate with their European counterparts on advancing towards EU membership, opening negotiating clusters, and taking other steps towards European integration.

On the other, decisions that are essential to both achieving full European integration and securing a substantial share of Western financial aid have been effectively sabotaged within Ukraine itself.

The issue, therefore, is not whether the government continues to proclaim its commitment to a European future, but whether Ukraine's political elite is prepared to relinquish its political stranglehold over the law enforcement agencies and other sensitive "assets" for the sake of European integration.

The answer can be found by examining Ukraine's actions on two parallel fronts: how the authorities are meeting the requirements for EU accession; and what they are actually doing to secure Western funding. These are the questions Ukrainska Pravda has been exploring.

EU accession: between reforms and a peace deal

Paradoxically, despite the domestic challenges facing the government in general and parliament in particular, in autumn 2026 Ukraine found itself on the verge of one of the biggest official breakthroughs in its EU accession process.

Ukraine has already succeeded in opening several negotiating clusters, and others are expected to open soon, Ukrainska Pravda sources in diplomatic circles say.

Kyiv has even managed to reach an understanding with Hungary's new government since the departure of Viktor Orbán, whose administration had spent years obstructing Ukraine's EU accession negotiations.

Ruslan Stefanchuk, Speaker of the Verkhovna Rada (Ukrainian parliament), secured the adoption of what was described as the world's first parliamentary resolution condemning Soviet repression against Hungarians after World War II. President Zelenskyy and Hungarian PM Péter Magyar finally held a face-to-face meeting, and Stefanchuk visited his Hungarian counterpart, Ágnes Forsthoffer. These developments have helped bring bilateral relations to a new level.

"We seem to have got relations with Hungary moving again. But now our relationship with Poland has deteriorated. Our people in the government believe these issues can be resolved. It's more about pride than anything else. Hungary used to block us, but Poland didn't. Now Poland wants to have a turn at blocking us," a senior figure in Zelenskyy's Servant of the People party tells Ukrainska Pravda with a smile.

Even if these diplomatic obstacles are overcome and the EU finally opens all the negotiating clusters, it will be far too soon to celebrate.

"Everyone's waiting for all the negotiating clusters to open – but that's when the hardest part begins, because it will all be up to us from then on," a source in the leadership of Ukraine's parliament explains. "The closing of individual negotiating chapters, let alone entire clusters, will depend entirely on whether we fulfil the requirements we've committed to."

And this is where Ukraine's governing team is running into serious trouble.

The European Union is becoming increasingly reluctant to treat Ukraine's EU accession process, domestic reforms and financial aid as separate matters.

Brussels has aligned a substantial proportion of its demands on Kyiv with those of the International Monetary Fund (IMF). As a result, the same reforms and legislative changes now appear in financial aid programmes and in the conditions Ukraine must meet to advance its EU membership negotiations.

And that means the Ukrainian authorities are gradually losing their ability to postpone politically difficult decisions indefinitely.

"We can meet some basic requirements within the negotiating clusters and pass relatively straightforward laws, and even difficult ones like the legislation on taxing parcels. But even so, unless we implement what's known as the Kachka-Kos plan, we won't get anywhere. And who's going to get that through parliament? Nobody has an answer to that," a senior member of the Servant of the People party tells Ukrainska Pravda, throwing up their hands. [The Kachka-Kos plan is named after Taras Kachka, Ukraine's former Deputy PM for European and Euro-Atlantic Integration and now Ukraine's Ambassador to the EU, and EU Enlargement Commissioner Marta Kos – ed.]

The 10-point plan, which is not officially part of the EU accession process but is informally seen as the main test of Ukraine's willingness to carry out reforms, primarily concerns changes to the procedures for appointing the heads of law enforcement agencies, strengthening the anti-corruption institutions' independence, and other measures.

While the government believes there is still some room for manoeuvre on certain issues, such as introducing a competitive selection process for the prosecutor general, other requirements are non-negotiable.

"Strictly speaking, we can't restrict the president's constitutional powers by introducing a [selection] board: that would directly contradict the Constitution," a senior member of Zelenskyy's team tells Ukrainska Pravda off the record, explaining the administration's position. "If the Constitution says the president nominates and appoints someone, then that's what he does. No selection board can make that decision for him. At most, we could establish an advisory group within the President's Office or elsewhere to draw up a shortlist of candidates."

In other words, the authorities are not considering a selection procedure modelled on the appointment of the director of the National Anti-Corruption Bureau of Ukraine (NABU), in which international experts have a decisive say. Indeed, Ukraine's new Deputy PM for European Integration, Vsevolod Chentsov, openly stated in an interview with European Pravda that the EU's requirements do not explicitly call for a selection board at the Prosecutor General's Office, let alone one modelled on those used to appoint the heads of NABU or the Bureau of Economic Security (BES), Ukraine's economic crime investigation agency.

Other requirements, however, offer no such flexibility. These include repealing the so-called Lozovyi amendments – controversial changes to Ukraine's criminal procedure legislation that affect investigations – and allowing criminal cases to be brought against members of parliament without the prosecutor general's approval.

"There are a lot of issues where there's absolutely no room for manoeuvre. If the requirement says NABU must be given the power to conduct its own independent forensic examinations, there's simply no way to get around that," one of the leaders of Zelenskyy's party admits.

As a result, the Ukrainian authorities are resorting to a form of quiet obstruction – and Brussels has noticed. This helps to explain why even Moldova, a much smaller country, outperformed Ukraine in the European Commission's latest assessment of the EU candidate countries. The progress Ukraine has made in areas such as tackling corruption has come about despite the actions of those in power rather than because of them.

EU officials can also see that while NABU and the Specialised Anti-Corruption Prosecutor's Office (SAPO) are uncovering high-level corruption, Ukraine's parliament has once again failed to adopt even an entirely toothless anti-corruption strategy.

Nevertheless, some of Ukraine's political leaders still hope the country might be able to join the EU through an alternative route – as part of a broader peace settlement ending Russia's war against Ukraine, rather than through the conventional accession process.

Indeed, during discussions about the framework for a future peace deal, the possibility of including EU membership for Ukraine in a wider package of arrangements covering the end of the war and security guarantees has been raised several times.

"It could be an entirely different mechanism. It doesn't exist yet, but it could be created," a source within Zelenskyy's team explains to Ukrainska Pravda. "It might resemble something that was discussed in earlier rounds of negotiations: a form of advance accession. The political decision would already have been made, you'd get the EU flag, some seats in the European Parliament, representation in the European Commission and so on. But access to the single market would be granted gradually as you fulfilled the requirements and closed the negotiating clusters."

The United States is not opposed to discussing EU membership for Ukraine as one element of a future peace settlement. According to Ukrainska Pravda sources familiar with the negotiations, the issue has been raised on several occasions.

But the EU itself has so far been reluctant not only to implement such an arrangement, but even to discuss it seriously at the negotiating table. One reason is that the EU has yet to appoint an authorised representative with a meaningful negotiating mandate. Another is that no legal framework currently exists to make such a form of accession possible.

"Our European partners are watching these latest negotiations with the Americans with interest, but they're trying to keep their distance for now. Because when someone says to them, 'Well, let's agree on security guarantees, put everything in writing and include EU membership,' they quickly disappear from negotiations for which they have no mandate," a member of Zelenskyy's team involved in the talks previously told Ukrainska Pravda.

So however attractive the prospect of early EU membership as part of a peace deal may seem to some Ukrainian politicians, it would be unwise to treat it as a guaranteed alternative to the established accession process.

And that means that for the foreseeable future, realistically, Ukraine's main route to EU membership remains the traditional, arduous, politically uncomfortable one: fulfilling its commitments, passing the necessary legislation, and carrying out reforms – reforms the Ukrainian authorities are unable to agree on even within Zelenskyy's own parliamentary majority.

Sabotage and political fears: why EU funding is stuck in Ukraine's parliament

While Ukraine's leadership has been busy on the international stage – trying to unblock EU accession negotiations, stepping up parliamentary diplomacy and improving relations with Hungary – a very different process has been unfolding at home.

The same government that publicly proclaims its determination to integrate Ukraine into the EU as quickly as possible has been systematically obstructing progress on meeting the commitments it made to its European partners.

The reason is relatively straightforward. Opening EU negotiating clusters, discussing the prospect of membership, debating Europe's future security architecture, even exploring the possibility of "reverse accession" as part of a future peace deal – these are all fairly abstract discussions about Ukraine's strategic future.

None of these discussions requires immediate political sacrifices. But when it comes to meeting the EU's specific political and economic requirements, that far-off future suddenly becomes a series of very concrete laws, decisions and unpopular reforms.

These range from reducing political influence over the law enforcement agencies to changing tax rules and utility tariff policies – measures that could cost those currently in power some of their influence and lose their parties votes.

The result has been a series of political confrontations in Ukraine's parliament. Perhaps the clearest example is the disruption of the EU's Ukraine Facility, a major financial assistance mechanism under which Ukraine receives funding in exchange for implementing reforms agreed with Brussels.

A substantial number of the measures Kyiv has promised to adopt have got stuck in the Verkhovna Rada.

So far, Ukraine has not actually lost the money allocated under the programme. Payments have simply been postponed. But the window for further delays is closing.

The final period in which Ukraine can apply for the relevant payments under the Ukraine Facility is the second quarter of 2027. If the legislation required under the programme hasn't entered into force by June 2027, that funding will be gone for good, with no possibility of claiming it later.

Oddly enough, Brussels has found itself repeatedly having to seek compromises and make concessions in order to provide Ukraine with the financial lifeline it desperately needs.

The situation is particularly absurd given Ukraine's latest requests for even more funding next year. In an interview, Zelenskyy said Ukraine is seeking an additional €70 billion in financial assistance for the coming year.

"We now need to try to negotiate with the Europeans for some extra cash," a source in the leadership of the Servant of the People party tells Ukrainska Pravda. "And ideally we need to secure it in advance, because next year there will be elections across Europe, some in key countries. The situation could become very unpredictable for Ukraine. But we have to give our European friends credit. They say €70 billion is a lot, but they're prepared to cover part of it."

"We're currently working to get Ukraine's funding needs included in the European three-year budget plans wherever possible," another senior parliamentary source explains. "We want the parliaments of key countries to incorporate our needs into their long-term financial commitments now so that it will be difficult to reverse those decisions later, even if the parties in power change."

***

Despite the government's obstruction and its reluctance to vote for measures that could jeopardise its own political interests, the realities of war and Ukraine's increasingly difficult economic situation are forcing MPs to do their jobs.

One revealing example was the government's "special operation" to freeze payments to the regions. The move effectively left MPs with a choice of either voting for unpopular legislation and securing much-needed funding for the country, or going back to their constituencies and explaining why payments in their regions had been blocked.

The parliamentary vote approving the state budget at first reading was equally telling.

"We're noticing that there are fewer demands and fewer political tantrums these days. Given everything that's happening around them, MPs seem to be showing a little more humility and acceptance of reality," one influential MP from the governing majority remarks with a touch of irony.

It seems Ukraine's lawmakers are gradually beginning to realise that there's no more room for political bargaining. Nor can they keep putting off difficult decisions for a rainy day. That rainy day has already dawned.

And although the reforms Europe is demanding are often painful for Ukrainian society – and even more so for those in power – one thing must be clearly understood: the question now is not whether Ukraine will join the European Union, but whether it can survive at all without joining.

Roman Romaniuk, Ukrainska Pravda

Translated by Myroslava Zavadska

Edited by Teresa Pearce

European integration Ukraine reforms money EU IMF
Advertisement: